治理研究 ›› 2025, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (2): 142-157.

• 法与治理 • 上一篇    

数字时代税法治理的范式调适

侯卓, 吴东蔚   

  • 收稿日期:2023-12-10 出版日期:2025-03-15 发布日期:2025-05-09
  • 作者简介:侯卓,中南财经政法大学法学院教授、博士生导师。
    吴东蔚,华南理工大学法学院博士研究生。

Paradigmatic Adaptation in Tax Law Governance for the Digital Era

Hou Zhuo, Wu Dongwei   

  • Received:2023-12-10 Published:2025-03-15 Online:2025-05-09

摘要:

数字时代的到来动摇了税法治理的基础假设。透过纳税客体无法充分识别数字主体的税负能力,凸显纳税人均质假设的解释力缺失;数字经济网络的“中心—边缘”图景深刻影响我国区域发展格局,区域均质假设的妥适性贬损,地方自主税收治理的需求陡增;数字经济崛起诱发社会事实复杂度升维,由社会事实向税法事实的转译进程受阻,社会事实可识别假设受到挑战。税法建制和运行需要将主体因素纳入量能课税的考量范围,结合数字经济地理图景对地方税权作差异化配置,同时基于有限认知理性,构建社会事实向税法事实的弹性化转译机制。在制度层面,使特定数字主体负担更重的纳税义务与协力义务,适度下放税收要素决定权,松绑类型化观察法,是因应数字时代而须实施的制度革新。

关键词: 数字经济, 税法治理, 量能课税, 税收法定, 税法事实

Abstract:

The advent of the digital age has undermined the foundational assumptions of tax law governance. The failure to adequately identify the tax-bearing capacity of digital subjects through taxable objects reveals the explanatory deficiency of the homogeneous taxpayer assumption. The “core-periphery” structure inherent in digital economic networks has reshaped China's regional development patterns, diminishing the appropriateness of the regional homogeneity assumption while intensifying demands for localized, autonomous tax governance. The rise of the digital economy has also induced multidimensional complexity in social facts. This obstructs the translation of social realities to tax law facts, thereby challenging the assumed verifiability of social facts. Thus, the construction and implementation of tax law must incorporate subjective factors into the measurement of taxable capacity under the ability-to-pay principle; configure local tax authority according to the digital economy's geographic characteristics; and, establish flexible mechanisms to translate social facts to tax law facts based on bounded cognitive rationality. At the institutional level, critical reforms should include imposing enhanced tax obligations and cooperative duties on specific digital entities, appropriately decentralizing determination power over tax elements, and relaxing categorization methodologies. These adaptations constitute the essential institutional innovations necessary to respond to digital transformation.

Key words: digital economy, tax law governance, ability-to-pay principle, statutory taxation, tax Law facts

中图分类号: