Welcome to Governance Studies ! Today is Share:
$ex.waitFor()

Most Download articles

    Published in last 1 year | In last 2 years| In last 3 years| All| Most Downloaded in Recent Month | Most Downloaded in Recent Year|

    In last 3 years
    Please wait a minute...
    For Selected: Toggle Thumbnails
    Adaptive Governance Research: Status and Future Prospects
    Rong Zhi, Tan Xiaofang
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (3): 111-126.  
    Abstract375)   HTML13)    PDF (1294KB)(3302)       Save

    With the expansion and deepening of human activities on ecosystems, adaptive governance has become an emerging governance mode to deal with the characteristics of multi-stability, non-linear, uncertainty, integrity, and complexity of complex systems. Adaptive governance is based on the theories of ecological resilience and self-organization. Its most prominent features are in its development-oriented concept and dynamic adaptability. It also has many realization paths, including core concepts such as multi-center and multi-level governance system, social network, and social learning. Adaptive governance in China arrived late and has not yet formed a theoretical system. Therefore, it is necessary to establish an adaptive governance system in line with China's politics, economy, and culture, by focusing on the nation’s experience. At the same time, adaptive governance research is also expanding to other fields, so we need to be cautious in the process of learning.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Bar Block Relationship: A Core Concept of China's Intergovernmental Relations
    Xu Dongtao
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (3): 34-44.  
    Abstract535)   HTML23)    PDF (951KB)(2085)       Save

    The bar block structure is the basic component of the Chinese government’s organizational system. The bar block relationship is a visual, conceptual, and theoretical expression of China's intergovernmental relations. It has inspired a surge in practical and theoretical research interest among China’s public management professionals. The evolution and development of the bar block relationship resonates with the construction and reform of the national system. Modernization of the national governance system and governance capacity will continue along with the concept of bar block relations as an important issue in government reform and public governance. For that reason, the connotations of bar block relations must be defined clearly, the main debates sorted out systematically, and the understanding of the regularity of bar block relations deepened. China’s independent knowledge system of public management requires interpreting the Chinese bar block relationship. Ideally, this analysis should not only be based on the history and reality of China's institutional structure and government reform practices. As such, it remains a universal theoretical concern for public management research. The bar block relationship may become more important in the practice and research of public management in China, contributing to the development of general theories of public management.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Institutional Innovation and Path Selection in China’s AI Legislation
    Yang Yanchao
    Governance Studies    2025, 41 (2): 20-37.  
    Abstract89)   HTML6)    PDF (1024KB)(1366)       Save

    The rapid rise of AI technologies like DeepSeek challenges modern legal systems’ values and rules. AI autonomy and decision-making disrupt our current legal foundations because they are based on human reason and morality, questioning justice, equality, and freedom. AI has also exceeded traditional rights and liability frameworks by introducing data and algorithmic rights while complicating legitimacy and responsibility allocation. China’s AI legislation must innovate by redefining legal subjects. AI should be treated as a tool with limited abstract subjectivity. Rights, duties, and responsibilities must be updated beyond the traditional static, fault-based models to suit AI’s dynamics. A dual-track “unified + sector-specific” legislative approach should address coordination, regulation, and global alignment. This will blend embedded innovation with independent oversight. Legislation should also balance innovation and risk through progressive laws and sandbox testing, ensuring adaptability and supporting AI’s healthy growth.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Between “Attention” and “Coping”: The Logic of Grassroots Government Response from the Perspective of Attention Allocation
    Ma Xuesong, Xiao Chuanlong
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (2): 94-108.  
    Abstract193)   HTML12)    PDF (1143KB)(1361)       Save

    Responsiveness is a fundamental attribute of democratic politics. Analyzing the operational logic of government response is a key step in improving responsiveness and enhancing efficiency. The responsiveness behavior of grassroots governments often lies between “attention” and “coping”. The perspective of attention allocation provides a powerful explanation for this. Grassroots governments follow the attention allocation logic of combining authority, interests, and avoidance of responsibility, and interact with the attention of superiors, officials, media, and the public, forming an attention allocation co-shaping mechanism. Under the influence of this logic and mechanism, grassroots governments exhibit four distinct response modes with varying governance effects: movement-type, coping-type, autonomy-type, and routine-type. Grassroots governments should take people’s real needs as the benchmark for response, use the logic and mechanism of attention allocation reasonably, and pay more attention to the consistency of response intensity, the effectiveness of response content, and the timeliness of response speed.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Common Features and Chinese Characteristics of the Chinese Path to Modernization
    Chen Xiyan, Chen Lixu
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (6): 23-30.  
    Abstract2891)   HTML71)    PDF (1196KB)(1108)       Save

    The Report of the 20th National Congress of the Communist Party of China pointed out that China’s “path to modernization is the socialist modernization led by the Communist Party of China. It has both the common features of the modernization of all countries and the Chinese characteristics based on its own national conditions.” The Chinese path to modernization is a model of modernization, with the common connotations and features of other modernizing countries. The characteristics of modernization may be the same across nations, but the path to achieving modernization is diverse and the western path is not the only model. China’s unique history, culture and basic national conditions such as “Late-developing”, “Parallel connection” and “Huge population”, mark the Chinese path to modernization with distinct characteristics. China must make its own development path suited to its characteristics. To promote Chinese-style modernization, China must “Always think of problems, make decisions and handle affairs in the light of its national conditions.”

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Building Application Scenarios for the Digital Transformation of Governance in China's Mega-Cities: Problem Orientation, Technological Application, and Performance Improvement
    Wu Jiannan, Ma Taiping, Zhang Acheng
    Governance Studies    2025, 41 (1): 4-18.  
    Abstract118)   HTML17)    PDF (2196KB)(1029)       Save

    The most tangible impact of the digital transformation of urban governance lies in the creation and innovation of standout application scenarios. Using content analyses of 103 cases from the Blue Book on Application Scenarios for the Digital Transformation of Urban Governance in China, this study reveals the problem domains, the technological applications, and the performance improvements in building application scenarios for digital transformation in mega-city governance. The findings indicate that, among the practicalities addressed by these scenarios, the most prominent are the “Efficiently Accomplish One Thing” issue and the “Efficiently Manage One Thing” issue. The key domains include smart governance, intelligent transportation, smart communities, and smart urban management, while areas such as smart environmental protection and intelligent security receive relatively less attention. Collaboration between governments and enterprises emerges as the most common approach in scenario development; however, the importance of citizen co-production and think tank participation is gradually increasing. Diverse technological applications are evident, with a focus on artificial intelligence and IoT-based sensing and monitoring technologies. These technologies are applied across the infrastructure, functional, and application layers, emphasizing the synergistic effects of different technology combinations to deliver comprehensive solutions for urban governance challenges. The application scenario development in existing cases has achieved performance improvements across the economic, efficiency, effectiveness, and equity dimensions. This study extends the discussion of digital transformation in urban governance from macro-level strategies to micro-level application scenarios, offering insights for mega-cities on selecting scenarios to achieve high-efficiency digital transformation.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Chinese Logic of Breaking 'Through the Bureaucratic Dilemma:Building a New' Type of National Governance Structure Under the Comprehensive Leadership of the CPC
    Ye Zipeng
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (1): 47-60.  
    Abstract109)   HTML7)    PDF (1093KB)(914)       Save

    Since the founding of People's Republic of China, the Communist Party of China ( CPC) has constructed a set of national governance structures different from that of China of the West. It has made substantial progress in exploring the application, transformation, and transcendence of the traditional bureaucracy. Since the i8th National Congress of the CPC,and especially in the past five years, the overall leadership of the CPC over the national governance structure is an important fulcrum to promote the modernization of the nation's govemance systemand govemance capability. This has helped achieve a high degree of mutual consistency between the logic of gover-ning the party and the logic of governing the country, thereby surpassing the traditional bureaucratic governancemodel, and fully stimulating the direction of modemn governance energy contained in the Chinese system. The newnational governance structure under the CPC is the organizational support for realizing the dialectical unity of poli-tics and administration in the process of China's modernization of national governance. Through the “political" leadership advantage, it effectively curbs the “dysfunction” of “administration", opening up a new way to elimi-nate the formalism and bureaucracy problems associated with bureaucracy.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Policy Spillover Effect: Definition, Classification and Mechanism Exploration
    Yang Kaifeng, Wang Lulu
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (3): 29-50.  
    Abstract415)   HTML12)    PDF (1403KB)(901)       Save

    Facing complicated domestic and international environments and the requirements of implementing systematic, integrated, and coordinated reforms, it is of great theoretical and practical significance to study policy spillover effects. However, the existing studies mainly focus on single or certain policy areas. Scholars seldom explore the general law and logic of policy spillovers. This study examines the varied phenomenon of policy spillovers, clarifies the definition, classification, core mechanisms, and the influencing factors of policy spillover effect. Future discussions should examine how to predict, monitor, and evaluate the policy spillover effect in a better way, and how to improve this process by improving methods, procedures and technologies, so as to deal with the possible negative policy spillovers.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (5): 25-34.  
    Abstract681)   HTML40)    PDF (1131KB)(899)       Save
    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    From “Harmony of man and nature” to “Harmony is precious”——Jurisprudential innovation and the practice of governance in ancient China
    He Qinhua, Zhang Shun
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (6): 31-42.  
    Abstract439)   HTML14)    PDF (1230KB)(840)       Save

    “Harmony of man and nature” is an outstanding achievement of ancient Chinese epistemology. Transforming it from a philosophical proposition into “Harmony is precious” in the political and legal practice of governing the country, and planning and arranging it in terms of legal concepts and systems, reflects the political wisdom and practical experience of the wise ministers and monarchs in ancient Chinese society. Beginning with a discussion of the relationship between “Harmony of man and nature” and “Harmony is precious”, this paper investigates the origins, connotations, evolution, and practice of the concept of harmony between man and nature. This includes the concept’s institutional embodiment in the Chinese legal system. Several traditional Chinese legal expressions value harmony, such as the preference for limiting, ceesing, and even barring litigation, the fusion of etiquette and law, and other ancient judicial practices. This paper posits that national concepts such as “Harmony of man and nature” and “Harmony is precious” still exert significant influence over the process of building a country under the rule of law in China.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Formation, Characteristics, and Practicalities of Urban Community Governance——A Qualitative Comparative Study of QCA Based on 56 cases
    Zhou Jinping, Zhou Pei
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (6): 93-104.  
    Abstract470)   HTML13)    PDF (1293KB)(765)       Save

    As the carrier of daily life and the basic governance unit, the urban community has important value. Building community governance is an important theoretical and practical issue that requires urgent study. This paper clarifys the basic connotations of community governance by examining it through the “Ties-Relations-Norms” analytical framework and the QCA qualitative comparative analysis of 56 urban community governance cases. We found that under the “party and government thrust” and “system guarantee” some communities have formed endogenous governance communities. They are characterized by a “co governance platform” and “community self-organization”. Characteristics of an incubating community governance community are its “interest guidance” and “professional support”. A community governance community under stress is characterized by its “Scene urgency” under specific scenarios. At present, it is necessary to strengthen the endogeneity of community governance dynamics, structural embeddedness and institutional effectiveness. At the same time, differentiated strategies should be adopted depending on the community and its governance circumstances. The goal is to gradually form a community of community governance in the context of bond cohesion, relationship connections, and normative guarantees.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Factors, Characteristics and Emotional Guidance Mechanism of the “Feminization Phenomenon” of Vrban Community Governance in China: A case Study Based on Nanyuan Street, Linping District, Hangzhou
    Lang youxing, Xing Shuyu
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (3): 106-117.  
    Abstract208)   HTML14)    PDF (1083KB)(755)       Save

    As women increase their participation in community governance, urban community governance becomes more feminized. Based on the community governance practices of four communities in Nanyuan Street, Linping District, Hangzhou, this paper analyzes the factors that form the feminization of urban community governance, summarizes the flexible role of characteristics and related behaviors, and focuses on the mechanism of emotional effects. As the study shows, the feminization of urban community governance is mainly related to institutional and cultural factors. Compared with male community workers, the feminized community tends to embrace flexible governance. Women emphasize consultation and cooperation, personal interactions, cultural and humanistic care, and the interests and needs of community members, all of which makes it is easier to form emotion-oriented action strategies in community governance. Through the accumulation and mechanism of five emotional elements (structural, situational, self-actualization, relevance, and internal acquisition), the process of community emotion-oriented governance is promoted.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (5): 45-58.  
    Abstract353)   HTML4)    PDF (1526KB)(742)       Save
    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Historical Basis, Political Essence and Practical Orientation of Xi Jinping’s Important Exposition on How to Escape the Historical Cycle of Rise and Fall
    Dong Ying, Huang Wei
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (6): 22-36.  
    Abstract181)   HTML9)    PDF (1143KB)(741)       Save

    Escaping the historical cycle of rise and fall is a major theme of Party building. It is also an examination of the Party’s long-term governance that Chinese Communists constantly consider, explore, and answer. Mao Zedong and Huang Yanpei’s “cave-dwelling conversation” revealed the dominant law of the historical cycle of rise and fall. It provided the first answer to the Party’s problem of breaking the historical cycle rate. It also provides an important historical basis for Xi Jinping’s exposition on how to escape the historical rise and fall cycle. Xi Jinping’s important statement is rich in c/onnotations, which explain the logical relationship between the historical cycle rate and the construction of the Marxist governing party, the centennial development of the Communist Party of China(CPC), and the rise and fall of Chinese and foreign historical dynasties and regimes. It emphasizes that the nature and purpose of the CPC are the decisive factors for the Party’s escape from the historical cycle rate. The people’s congress system is an effective guarantee for national governance to jump out of the historical cycle rate. Self-reform is the second method for the Party to break out of the historical cycle rate. On the new journey forward, we will rejuvenate the Chinese nation on all fronts through a Chinese path to modernization and an expansion into new forms of human achievement. The Party will rely externally on people’s democracy and supervision and internally on full and rigorous self-governance and the Party’s self-reform. The Party will promote the “Three Non-corruptions” as a whole and comprehensively build a “Clean China”, pledging “our political environment will, through tireless efforts, like seas fallen calm and rivers running clear, be clean and free of corruption.” These efforts will ensure that the CPC, as the nation’s long-term governing party, will never change its nature, its conviction, or its character.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (5): 93-101.  
    Abstract374)   HTML12)    PDF (1237KB)(711)       Save
    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Digital Technologies promote equalization of public services between urban and rural areas: mechanism and practical logic
    Shi Xinjie, Cui Liu, Fu Changluan
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (2): 109-123.  
    Abstract438)   HTML16)    PDF (1858KB)(698)       Save

    Equalization of public services between urban and rural areas is one of the important pathways to realize rural revitalization and common prosperity. At present, the equalization of public services in China faces many challenges, including big differences in the supply of public services between urban and rural areas, insufficient endogenous supply of rural public services, and low efficiency of public service provision. As an emerging technology, digital technologies provide a new way to solve urban and rural public service equalization issues. After defining the relevant concepts and interpreting several theories, this paper constructs a theoretical framework about how digital technologies promote the equalization of public services between urban and rural areas. According to this framework, we analyze the cases of practice related to the digital empowerment of urban and rural public services equalization in Zhejiang province. We propose three optimization routes: first, reinforcing the top-level design and breaking the barrier of the development of digital technologies; second, using local features to drive the endogenous supply of public services through industry digitization; and facilitating factor mobility and enhancing the universality and inclusiveness of public services with digital technology.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Special Work Team :New-style Deliberative and Coordinating Agency in China
    Liu Peng, Liu Zhipeng
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (1): 13-22.  
    Abstract466)   HTML19)    PDF (1063KB)(650)       Save

    Max Weber's suggestion that bureaucracy originatcs from modern society has some shortcomings, such as institution design deficiency and an inability to respond to social transitions. Therefore,as China’s newtype of deliberative and coordinatig agency, the Special Work’Team can be found at various levels of the Party andgovernments. It promotes inter-departmental cooperation and responds to exernal uncertainties. The Team attends topolicy implementation promotion and accomplishing governance tasks by targeting individual responsibility and focu-sing government attention. This article defines the Special Work’Team concept,clarifies its main types, and analy-zes the academic discussion around the concept. From the perspective of comparative study, the characteristics andmechanisms of the Special Work Team concept were analyzed through a summary of debates from current research. From the perspective of bureaucracy, this paper provides an analytical framework to investigate the functions andmechanisms of the Special Work Team in optimizing the hierarchical system.Finally, the future of Special WorkTeam research is described.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    How Does Multi-Agent Collaborative Governance Promote the Co-production of Public Services?——An Institutional Analysis Based on the “Village FA” in R County
    Zhang Youlang, Ran Yuhao
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (2): 57-72.  
    Abstract303)   HTML13)    PDF (1784KB)(550)       Save

    The co-production of public services is crucial to building a people-centered social governance community. This study proposes a framework of multi-agent collaborative governance (MCG) in co-production and takes the “Village FA” in R County as a case study to explore the impact of MCG on co-production. The research reveals that “Village FA” represents a co-production model involving the participation of society, government, and market actors, which stems from the public's self-organizing behavior. MCG enhances the effectiveness of co-production through mechanisms of social incubation, market facilitation, agenda absorption, and administrative empowerment. Co-production under MCG is the result of interactions among multiple levels of action stages with distinct phase characteristics, thus the application of these mechanisms necessitates consideration of their adaptability. This study contributes by integrating co-production theory with collaborative governance theory, thereby expanding the theoretical framework of co-production. Furthermore, it provides an empirical illustration of the mechanisms and institutionalization process of co-production in Chinese context.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Can the Metaverse Promote Public Participation in Social Governance? A Five-level Scaffold Analysis
    Pan Haozhi, Lyu Shoujun, Chen Jie
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (6): 81-92.  
    Abstract343)   HTML14)    PDF (1519KB)(543)       Save

    “Technological empowerment” in the digital transformation of social governance aims to promote public participation and collaboration in decision-making through emerging technologies. But can it really increase the public’s power? For example, the Metaverse provides the channel and media for communication between the public and government. But the new technology can also be exploited by techno-capitalists to pursue a corporate and technocratic society. This paper examines these questions through a five-level scaffold conceptualization to enrich the discourse of the “technological empowerment” of the Metaverse. The conceptualization is used to distinguish the types and extent of technology empowerment for different stakeholders in social governance within the Metaverse. The five different levels in the scaffold, from low to high, include “corporate technocrat”,“tokenism interaction”, “public participation”, “co-creation and collaboration”, and “delegated power”. In every level of the five-level scaffold, keyword search is used to identify and explain the corresponding roles and cases of the public in social governance. The results show that “co-creation and collaboration” is a promising approach that can be scaled up under current social governance conditions and is a feasible direction for digital transformation. Application of the Metaverse in technological empowerment can be well-guided by “co-creation and collaboration”. At the same time, the five-level scaffold conceptualization also warns of the risks of technolo-capitalists’ pushing a neoliberal agenda by applying Metaverse technology to evade regulation.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Evolutionary Game Analysis of Multi agent Behavior Strategies in the Digital Transformation of Government Services
    Xia Zhiqiang, Zhao Yuxin
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (6): 84-99.  
    Abstract158)   HTML9)    PDF (2153KB)(538)       Save

    The digital transformation of government services is an important method for local governments to promote the modernization of governance. When promoting the digital transformation of government affairs, there are different goals, positions, and interests between the central government, local governments, digital technology enterprises, and the public which result in ineffective cooperation. The article focuses on the multi-agent collaboration mechanism in the digital transformation process of government services and constructs a game model between the central government, local governments, digital technology enterprises, and the public. By conducting simulation analysis on the model, the article reveals the evolutionary game process, ideal equilibrium state, and influencing factors of strategy selection of the four participants and explores the best collaborative strategies for multiple entities. Research has found that the central government attaches great importance to reputation and smooth governance. Local governments and digital enterprises are more concerned about additional costs. And the quality of government service supply affects the trust of the public and forms a positive cycle with public participation and supervision. Therefore, the development focus should be on the digital government responsibility of local governments, while also reducing their burden to supply services. The central government should strengthen the supervision of digital government services, safeguard the public interest, and enhance government credibility. Digital technology enterprises need to enhance their sense of social responsibility and help the public integrate into digital life.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Optimization of the Party Rules on the United Front Work of the Communist Party of China
    Song Jian, Zhou Di
    Governance Studies    2025, 41 (1): 100-116.  
    Abstract45)   HTML2)    PDF (987KB)(516)       Save

    The optimization of the Party rules on United Front Work of the Communist Party of China (CPC) is essential in the context of the comprehensive advancement of law-based governance. Since the 18th National Congress of the CPC, with the formulation of relevant Party regulations and normative documents, the regulation of United Front Work has significantly improved in terms of institutional, normative, and procedural aspects. However, content and structure problems still exist; and the regulations lack coordination. The CPC's leadership should also be strengthened and improved by clarifying the logic of the regulation system; formulating the executive, supervisory, and supportive regulations; and, improving the accuracy of regulatory expression and the suitability of information disclosure.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Political Logic and Basic Management of the Systemic Improvement of Party Governance
    Liu Honglin
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (6): 4-12.  
    Abstract405)   HTML26)    PDF (1214KB)(509)       Save

    Strictly Party governance is the fundamental requirement of Marxist political parties and the way to self-strengthen the Communist Party of China in its century-long development. In the new era, the comprehensive and strict governance of the Party is not only meant to solve the general and specific problems faced by the Party's construction, but also to effectively solve the unique problems besetting its long-term governance. This is also meant to aid the Party remove itself from its historical cycles. To improve the Party’s system of strict governance, reform must be built into the Party's organizational system and structure. This must be done in accord with the general requirements of the Party's construction in the new era, and it must be based on and guaranteed by the system of intra Party laws and regulations. We must adhere to scientific concepts and systematic thinking. We must focus on preventing power alienation and instead push to integrate all the elements of strict governance of the Party, making it a structured rather than flat organic system. Fundamentally, the system of strict governance of the Party in an all-round way is a set of institutional mechanisms consisting of dynamism, responsibility, management, supervision, accountability, rewards, punishments, etc. The key is to further realize the organic unity and supporting operation of the systems related to responsibility, supervision, and accountability within the Party.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Mass Supervision and Government Response Driven by Digital Platforms——A Supervision Information Platform in the Field of People's Livelihood in Province A
    Wang Rui, Ni Xing
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (2): 124-138.  
    Abstract215)   HTML16)    PDF (1723KB)(494)       Save

    The concept of technology empowerment has promoted the transformation of digital government. The interaction between the government and the people relying on digital platforms has gradually become the main field of political communication and dialogue. With the perspective of system theory and the help of structural topic model (STM), 20,660 items of complaints and reports and government responses on an information platform that monitors people's livelihoods in province A were analyzed tostudy the role of digital platforms on the interaction between the government and the people. The study’s findings show the digital platform relied on high-efficiency data collection, information transmission, and data processing. In doing so, it provided an opportunity for change in the convenience of mass supervision and the effectiveness of the government’s response. At the management level, the platform was the hub, enabling the content and the mode of the government’s response to be dynamically adjusted according to the categories of complaints. Institutionally, the full-process supervision model was deeply integrated with the interactions between the government and the people to promote and guarantee the public's right to supervision. Through the processing of large-scale unstructured texts, this study provides a new perspective for understanding public supervision and government response.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Contemporary French Marxism as Political Philosophy
    Bao Dawei
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (6): 63-71.  
    Abstract254)   HTML2)    PDF (1156KB)(486)       Save

    Over a century of theoretical evolution, French Marxists introduced dialectics, through Hegelianism, into the political conception of socialism. At the same time, through the translation and discussion of Karl Marx's early philosophical works, it triggered a humanist and existential vision of Marxist political views. In the ongoing controversy full of political factors, contemporary French Marxists have reflected on the positive and negative experiences of socialist revolutionary practice in the past century. They have also inherited the unfinished practice of political emancipation from the 20th century while criticizing the contemporary symptoms of capitalist ideology. The historical burdens of theory and practice pushed contemporary French Marxists to divide principle from strategy This took the form of trying to completely abandon political ethics to reconstruct the relationship between “meta-politics” and historical materialism while trying to suspend the critique of modern capitalist democracy in governance and order.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (5): 59-72.  
    Abstract407)   HTML11)    PDF (2713KB)(484)       Save
    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Listing Supervision and the Institutional Innovation of the Chinese Supervision System
    Chen Hongcai, Zhang Zexing
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (2): 44-56.  
    Abstract214)   HTML10)    PDF (1226KB)(484)       Save

    The listed supervision system is now being used to deal with increasingly complex safety governance issues. Developed for social security governance and then used for ecological environmental protection, production safety and other fields, the system creatively integrates the supervision mechanism with Chinese characteristics into the complex governance scene. It has achieved remarkable governance results across regulatory fields. As a key facet of Chinese public management, it has been frequently used and studied in recent years. The political pressure, social pressure, and time pressure contained in listing supervision combine to form strong political potential energy. This prompts supervision objects such as local governments and their functional departments to immediately strengthen their political execution, organizational coordination, and social response. It is the signal that central policy objectives must be completed in a relatively short period of time. In this case, it was used to improve the efficiency of safety governance. Despite this record of success, we should adhere to a rational and scientific attitude when objectively evaluating the governance performance of the listed supervision office. On this basis, scholars can clarify the listed supervision system’s effectiveness boundaries, identify the underlying logic of its operation with higher quality research work, and develop countermeasures therefrom to ensure it always plays a positive function.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Policy Experimentation: An Important Mechanism in Chinese Public Policy
    HuangBia
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (1): 23-32.  
    Abstract216)   HTML18)    PDF (1118KB)(480)       Save

    Policy experimentation is a crucial mechanism deeply rooted in China's public policy system,standing as one of the keywords in China's contemporary public administration. Experimentation-based policyprocesses in China significantly differ from the processes in Western countries, as it bypasses extensive poliey discussions regarding agenda setting and scheme selection. The government authorizes selected localities to practice anew policy on a trial basis before its formal implementation. The appropriateness of vague policy objectives are ex-amined as instruments are explored and pathways investigated to achieve policy goals. Policy experimentation re-duces the possibility of policy disputes leading to unresolved issues and decreases the adjustment costs and potentialrisks of implementaiton. It has become a vital source of adaptability in Chinese public policy. Although policy ex-perimentation may not yield the expected results, China's current structural conditions and institutional foundationssupport its overall effectiveness. ln pursuit of building China 's independent public administration knowledge base,further research should clarify the concept of policy experimentation,reveal the multiple logics behind it, and con-struct principles for conducting policy experimentation.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    From Economic Development to Social Governance: An Analysis of Social Stability in China through a Demand-Response Framework
    Yan Jirong
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (2): 4-19.  
    Abstract398)   HTML336)    PDF (1653KB)(480)       Save

    It is commonly believed that economic development inevitably leads to social instability during modernization. However, China's experience demonstrates that sustained economic development and long-term social stability can complement and strengthen one another. This article examines the long-term evidence of China's economic development since the reform and opening-up, using the lens of “social governance” advocated by the Chinese government to explore how long-term social stability can be achieved in China. The article argues that the Chinese government's continuous promotion of social administration innovation and social governance reform has significantly contributed to maintaining social stability. These measures have not only resolved social conflicts and reduced social instability, but also pressured the government to reform and improve its responsiveness. China's experience suggests that an analysis of social stability based on the demand-response framework holds explanatory power.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Logic of Digital Technology Driving the Territorial Operation of Bureaucratic Organizations:A Case Study of the “Four Platforms of Grassroots Governance” in Zhejiang Province
    Tang Jinghua
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (1): 40-52.  
    Abstract374)   HTML27)    PDF (1127KB)(467)       Save

    Digital technology drives the operations of bureaucratic organizations. But how? Based on the case of Zhejiang Province’s “Four Platforms of Grassroots Governance” , this paper uses “territorial operation” to explore the tendency of digital government’s operational logic to allow technology to drive bureaucratic organizations to construct decision-making and action strategies according to modular or systematic thinking, which helps strengthen government’s overall response to real problems. This transformation manifests by changing the action mode from segmentation to integration, changing the organizational relationship from linear connections to an interactive network, changing the value pursuit from departmental performance to overall efficiency, etc. “Territorial operations” transcends the departmentalized operations of traditional bureaucratic organizations, which helps to enhance the government's response to complex social problems. Such modifications are not easily achieved. They face the constraints of bureaucratic inertia, the application of digital technology, and the tension between technology simplicity and reality complexity. The territorial operational logic expands the research perspective of digital government governance as well as provides a new explanatory framework for understanding the transformation of bureaucratic organizations driven by digital technology.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (5): 102-112.  
    Abstract424)   HTML23)    PDF (1794KB)(459)       Save
    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Campaign-Style Governance: A Mobilization Mechanism with Chinese Characteristics
    Xiang Miao
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (3): 24-33.  
    Abstract294)   HTML9)    PDF (950KB)(452)       Save

    Campaign-style governance is rooted in traditional Chinese politics. It has also become the keyword of Chinese public administration with its widespread presence in contemporary Chinese national and local governance. There is a relationship between campaign-style governance mechanisms and hierarchical governance, which includes substitution, complementarity, and synergy. This association is an important experience in the revolution, construction, and development of contemporary China, reflecting the institutional advantages and governance effectiveness of Chinese state governance. However, campaign-style governance mechanisms also face the dilemma of effectiveness and the paradox of legitimacy caused by the layering of targets and the distortion of goals. A future pathway will embrace an institutionalized governance that is standardized, observe the rule of law, and focus on long-term effectiveness. Accordingly, campaign-style governance mechanisms will restrict public goals as well as provide technical, normative, and procedural constraints. Although campaign-style governance has distinctive Chinese characteristics, it is deeply related to bureaucratic governance, mobilization politics, and holistic governance. It has a wide range of applicability in both developing countries and developed countries. As both a theoretical concept and a governance mechanism, it is both country specific and universal regarding global public governance.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Scientific Logic and Time Value of Xi Jinping's Important Discourse on Common Prosperity in the New Era
    Xu Guang, Wang Xiaoyan
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (2): 67-79.  
    Abstract157)   HTML7)    PDF (1031KB)(447)       Save

    The 20th National Congress of the Communist Party of China (CPC) pointed out that the Chinese path to modernization is the modernization of achieving common prosperity for all people. Achieving common prosperity for all people is the essential requirement of the Chinese path to modernization. Since the 18th National Congress of the CPC, the Party Central Committee with Xi Jinping as the core has put forward a series of new ideas and assertions around the strategic goal, key tasks and realization path of common prosperity. This has gradually formed a scientific logic with profound connotations and views. Xi Jinping's important exposition of common prosperity in the new era is the dialectical unity of the theoretical logic of the common prosperity thought of Marxism’s classical writers, the historical logic of the common prosperity thought elements in China's excellent traditional culture, and the practical logic of the CPC's pursuit of common prosperity for a hundred years. Through the mutual unity of the connotation, characteristics, and strategic objectives of common prosperity, promotion principles and implementation measures, and key tasks and institutional arrangements, Xi Jinping's important statement on common prosperity effectively responds to the theoretical disputes about common prosperity in the new era, clarifies the goal of common prosperity in the new development stage, and provides practical methodological guidance for the solid promotion of common prosperity. It has important theoretical innovation value and practical guiding significance.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Social Justice Risks in the Age of AI: What Kind of Society? What are the Risks?
    Li Meng
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (3): 118-129.  
    Abstract229)   HTML15)    PDF (1090KB)(430)       Save

    The social risks caused by artificial intelligence (AI) are rooted in the injustice of an AI society. In order to more comprehensively understand the social justice risks of AI, it is necessary to analyze the social form of the era of AI based on Marxism. From the perspective of “production justice”, an AI society is one of deeply automated production, which may lead to production justice risks such as downward aggregation of labor, weakening of labor capacity, and labor “dividuum”. From the perspective of “distributive justice”, an AI society is one of great material abundance but serious unfairness to individuals, in terms of spatial and time distribution. From the perspective of “cognitive justice”, an AI society combines the virtual and the real, which may lead to the risk of cognitive justice, such as rational cognitive deprivation, self-control deprivation, and independent choice deprivation. From the perspective of “development justice”, the contradictions and tensions between AI and human society may lead to development justice problems such as energy competition, imbalance of rights and responsibilities, and passive resistance, all of which can weaken society’s motivation to pursue justice. The fundamental cause of the “justice risk” of an AI society lies in the contradiction between the world’s limited resources and the unlimited demands of human beings and AI. The core incentive lies in the inherent social injustice of human society itself. And the biggest obstacle is that the existing governance methods are unsuited to act directly on the responsible subjects in the field of AI. To this end, it is necessary to reasonably delineate the energy consumption standards and proportions of AI development, focus on solving the unjust problems in traditional society, and penetrate the “black box of responsibility” of AI for the purpose of human development.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Governance Studies    2022, 38 (5): 73-82.  
    Abstract633)   HTML25)    PDF (1051KB)(409)       Save
    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Algorithmic Governance of Labor Rights in the Digital Age: Generative Logic and Optimization Path
    WU Shuai, SHI Jiawei, ZHU Danyu
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (5): 147-156.  
    Abstract219)   HTML10)    PDF (1436KB)(408)       Save

    In the digital age, the management of the labor has undergone great changes. New requirements are needed for the algorithmic governance of workers. This paper discusses the generative logic and optimization path of algorithmic governance in the digital labor scene, starting from the control of the algorithmic labor process. The lack of algorithmic governance of workers has brought new changes to controlling workers’time, space and assessments. These changes have inspired workers to seek new protections for their rights and interests. Their demands mainly include off-line rest, humanization of labor rules and fairness in pay deductions. The protection of workers’ rights and interests calls for an optimization strategy of “algorithmic good governance”, which requires us to move from disorder to a conscious and deliberate order.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Multiple Synergy and Grassroots Sinking: Research on the Grassroots Level Practice of Chinese Urban Cultural Governance
    Song Daolei, Guo Sujian
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (1): 125-135.  
    Abstract243)   HTML13)    PDF (1074KB)(407)       Save

    Since the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, urban cultural governance has received increasing attention from academic circles. China's urban cultural governance has gradually transformed from a government-led model to a model of the coordinated participation of multiple subjects. The spatial practice mechanism of urban cultural governance is also changing. The multiple coordinated governance network, which is composed of political party leadership, government responsibility, social participation, and citizen autonomy, allows urban cultural governance to percolate to the grassroots. With China’s large-scale urban cultural infrastructure, it is possible for urban cultural governance to reach a city's smaller grassroots spaces. The practice of urban cultural governance with the participation of multiple subjects has promoted the urban grass-roots blocks and communities to become cultural spaces that meet the needs of ordinary citizens. These important spatial places have allowed urban cultural governance to expand to the grass-roots level.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    Understanding the Basic Dimension of Social Justice Risk in Artificial Intelligence——Analysis Path Based on Marx's Viewpoint of Distributive Justice
    Qi Guang, Zhang Meng
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (3): 130-142.  
    Abstract174)   HTML16)    PDF (1100KB)(404)       Save

    The rapid development and wide application of artificial intelligence has brought great social wealth, but it has also hidden the inevitable risk of distributive justice. As a basic theory of analysis, Marx's viewpoint of distributive justice is a common logic paradigm for different understanding and analysis. Based on criticizing and deconstructing the capitalist mode of production, Marx constructed the distributive justice viewpoint, which has production justice as its fundamental premise, labor equality as its value stipulation, and the promotion of freedom and comprehensive development of human beings as its practical purpose. In this theoretical framework, the essential problem of artificial intelligence and distributive justice lies in the ‘Wealth Distribution Paradox’, which is rooted in the capitalist application of artificial intelligence and manifested as the continuous intensification of productive injustice, labor inequality, and the complete loss of human essence. Therefore, the exclusive way to reverse this contradiction is to thoroughly criticize and jump out of the logic of capital when the new ethical risk of artificial intelligence is presented. Only in this way can the real social application of artificial intelligence be realized and the formal system of distribution be transformed into the substantial presentation of creation.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Theoretical Basis, Practical Dilemma, and Development Orientation of Digital Procuratorate Reform
    Hu Meikui
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (2): 141-155.  
    Abstract213)   HTML7)    PDF (1042KB)(397)       Save

    As an important part of the construction of “Digital China”, digital prosecution has promotes the reconstruction and reform of the legal supervision mode. At present, digital prosecution is still in the early stage of development. Therefore, it is urgent to strengthen basic theoretical research and promote a plan of reform by centering the digitalization of the operation mechanism of procuratorial power. This should begin by clarifying the concept connotations and historical context of digital prosecution. Reform efforts should also further demonstrate the legal basis for digital prosecution. The current digital prosecution reform’s difficulties include a case handling process that has not yet been conceptualized, a lack of data analysis and judgment abilities, a data system that is not standardized, and case teams that require greater professionalization. After reviewing the procuratorial power theory and its operational practice, this article suggests specific reforms to solve these problems. Basic guidelines should be adopted for the implementation of reform measures that will lay the foundation for the integration of digital procuratorial reform into the broader national governance system.

    Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Influence Mechanism and Practical Path of Common Prosperity in Rural Areas An Investigation of 80 Villages in common prosperity unions in Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province
    Xu Yueqian, Chen Lan
    Governance Studies    2024, 40 (1): 92-108.  
    Abstract190)   HTML10)    PDF (1115KB)(396)       Save

    Promoting common prosperity in rural areas is an important part of achieving common prosperity forall people. Stimulating rural endogenous power is the key to continuously promoting common prosperity. Such development has become the core issue of the modernization of rural govermance.Among the first 80 villages in the common prosperity unions in Hangzhou, factors such as party building, capable people, industry, and culture were im-portant variables affecting the realization of common prosperity through the mixed method of NCA and QCA. Despite the multitude of variables, common prosperity through endogenous development can be characterized as four “different paths": partner collaboration,cultural identity,industrial integration and comprehensive development, andthe generation of rural internal power. However, the changes in endogenous mechanisms are alternating and dynamically evolving. Therefore,measures must be adjusted to local conditions and integrated with local resources,geo-graphic features, and other conditions. lt is also necessary to consider the spatial layout, the characteristics of thedifferentiation development path, and the acceleration of brand-building.This will enrich the theoretical researchof rural common prosperity as well as provide useful enlightenment for other regions to choose matching rural endogenous development strategies.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics
    The Special Challenges of Large Party from the Perspective of Organization Theory
    Zheng Huan
    Governance Studies    2023, 39 (3): 73-87.  
    Abstract118)   HTML4)    PDF (1095KB)(393)       Save

    As the largest Marxist governing party in the world, the Communist Party of China (CPC) has always been alert and determined to tackle the special challenges that large parties face. According to the party organization literature, these are the impacts of membership growth on the party’s structure and organizational behavior. The actual challenges for large political parties are manifold: imbalances between the quantity and quality of party members, between centralization and decentralization of power, rising collective action of party members, and organizational complexity. Many large parties have failed to balance these internal relationships, leading to disastrous results. From the perspective of organizational theory, we can identify the special challenges faced by the CPC.

    Table and Figures | Reference | Related Articles | Metrics