治理研究 ›› 2022, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (1): 50-65.

• 环保督察研究专题 • 上一篇    下一篇

元治理视阈下中央环保督察制度的省思与完善

李媛媛, 郑偲   

  • 收稿日期:2021-06-08 出版日期:2022-01-15 发布日期:2022-02-18
  • 作者简介:李媛媛,法学博士,浙江农林大学文法学院副教授,浙江省重点专业智库宁波大学东海研究院研究员;郑偲,浙江农林大学文法学院硕士研究生。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金项目“农村合作金融的法律监管问题研究”(20BFX155)

Reflecting on the Path to Optimizing the Central Environmental Inspection System from the Perspective of Meta-Governance

Li Yuanyuan, Zheng Si   

  • Received:2021-06-08 Published:2022-01-15 Online:2022-02-18

摘要:

中央环保督察制度的生成逻辑包括“对常规型环保治理机制的矫正纠偏”和“对环境问责制度的弥补与强化”。前者与中央环保督察制运行程序下产生的动员压力一起指向“社会协同、公众参与”的特征;后者与中央环保督察制度组织架构下产生的问责压力一起指向“党委领导、政府负责”的特征。但从长远来看,在法治思维下,中央环保督察制度存在“行政权力过度依赖与长效机制缺位”“多元治理乏力”的弊端和困境。元治理通过对自组织的组织和对治理的治理,既倡导多元治理主体的依存与合作,又强调国家在治理中的主体地位,保留了政府的影响力。这与中央环保督察制度所践行的“党委领导、政府负责、社会协同、公众参与”的环境治理逻辑具有契合性。其对中央环保督察制度中的法治进程推进、政府角色重塑、治理模式协调等方面的优化提供了参考方向。

关键词: 元治理, 环境治理, 中央环保督察, 政府角色, 治理责任

Abstract:

The formation logic of environmental supervision by the central government includes restoring the environmental governance mechanisms and strengthening the environmental accountability system. The center provides mobilization pressure through its environmental supervision system and relies on social coordination and public participation. Accountability pressure is generated under the organizational structure of the central environmental protection supervision system which relies on party committee leadership and government responsibility. This is not sustainable under a rule-of-law system. The disadvantages and difficulties include excessive dependence on administrative power, the absence of a long-term mechanism, and weak multi-governance. Through organization of self-organization and governance of governance, meta-governance advocates for the dependence and cooperation of multiple governance subjects, emphasizes the dominant position of the state, and retains the influence of the government. This is in line with the governance logic of party committee leadership, government responsibility, social coordination, and the public participation practiced by the central environmental supervision system. It provides a reference direction for rule-of-law process as it is optimized in the environmental inspection system, the reconstruction of government's role, and the coordination of governance modes.

Key words: Meta-governance, environmental governance, central environmental protection supervision, government role, governance responsibility

中图分类号: