治理研究 ›› 2023, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (5): 52-65.

• 国家治理·公共政策研究专题 • 上一篇    下一篇

重新理解公共政策变迁:基于危机学习的知识管理视角

文宏, 李风山   

  • 收稿日期:2023-05-23 出版日期:2023-09-15 发布日期:2023-11-01
  • 作者简介:文宏,华南理工大学公共管理学院教授、博士生导师
    李风山,华南理工大学公共管理学院博士研究生
  • 基金资助:
    教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目“重大突发公共卫生事件背景下的城市治理研究”(21JZD037)

A New Understanding of Public Policy Change: A Knowledge Management Perspective based on Crisis Learning

Wen Hong, Li Fengshan   

  • Received:2023-05-23 Published:2023-09-15 Online:2023-11-01

摘要:

理解公共政策变迁是政策过程研究的核心议题。已有研究提出了多源流理论、间断均衡理论和倡导联盟框架等经典解释,但相对忽略了知识管理视角下危机学习对公共政策变迁的作用机制。基于全面“禁野”政策变迁的案例,研究提出公共政策变迁的危机学习新解释:(1)焦点事件触发下的“激活机制”为危机学习打开了“机会窗口”,促进了危机情境下的知识生产,构成了政策变迁的起始条件;(2)话语争夺场域中的“演化机制”呈现出差异性的话语叙事和社会建构,本质是一种知识竞争,能够实现对政策问题的再定义;(3)领导注意力作用下的“反馈机制”促使隐性知识转化为显性知识,推动经验层面的认知判断向制度化的政策规范转变。“知识生产—知识竞争—知识转化”的危机学习过程框架有助于揭示危机学习推动政策变迁的黑箱机制,不仅丰富了公共政策变迁的解释图谱,而且进一步拓展了危机学习的研究边界。

关键词: 危机学习, 政策变迁, 知识管理, 间断均衡, 全面“禁野”

Abstract:

Understanding public policy change is a central topic in policy process research. Classical explanations such as multiple streams theory, intermittent equilibrium theory, and the advocacy coalition framework are well-known. But the mechanism of crisis learning for public policy change from the perspective of knowledge management has been relatively neglected. Based on the case of “Complete Fasting for Wild Animals”, this study proposed an explanatory path of crisis learning for public policy change. It was found that: (1) the “activation mechanism” triggered by the focal event opens a “window of opportunity” for crisis learning, which promotes knowledge production in the crisis situation and constitutes the starting condition for policy change. (2) The “evolution mechanism” in the field of discursive competition, which presents different discursive narratives and social construction, is essentially a kind of knowledge competition that can realize the redefinition of policy issues. (3) The “feedback mechanism” under the leadership’s attention can prompt the transformation of tacit knowledge into explicit knowledge and promote the transformation of empirical cognitive judgments into institutionalized policy norms. The crisis learning process framework of “knowledge production-knowledge competition-knowledge transformation” reveals more of the black-box mechanism of crisis learning to promote policy change. This enriches the explanatory map of public policy change, but also further expands the research boundary of crisis learning.

Key words: crisis learning, policy change, knowledge management, punctuated equilibrium, complete fasting for wild animals

中图分类号: